If Simpson replicated his 2024 season, he would currently be on track to earn a substantial pay raise on the 2026 free agent market. However, at 28 years old, NFL teams will not be eager to sign Simpson to a long-term deal into his thirties with the type of production he generated through the first 11 games of this season. To this point, he has lost tens of millions of dollars through his play in 2025.
There is still enough time for Simpson to get back on the trajectory he found himself on after the 2024 season. A dominant six-game stretch could raise his season-long numbers back up to their 2024 levels.
If it’s going to happen, he must start on Sunday by maximizing a favorable matchup against Atlanta.
The Falcons’ primary right-side defensive tackle is Ruke Orhorhoro. Simpson will see a bit of every Falcons defensive tackle, as Atlanta rotates its defensive linemen, but Orhorhoro leads the interior unit with 23.3 snaps per game on the right side (across from the left guard), so he will be Simpson’s primary matchup.
The 2024 second-round pick has not lived up to expectations so far. Orhorhoro is PFF’s lowest-ranked defensive tackle among 83 qualifiers with at least 300 defensive snaps (41.4 overall grade). He only has three quarterback hits in 11 games, while he has struggled immensely against the run.
At the moment, Simpson’s 2025 metrics are substantially below where they were in 2024. If he wants to make up that ground in just six games, he must be not only good, but outstanding. And he’s capable of it; after all, he was PFF’s fourth-ranked guard last year.
A matchup against one of the league’s least effective defensive tackles is just what the doctor ordered for Simpson. Let’s see if he can take advantage.
From the Jets’ perspective, Simpson is a fascinating evaluation. If he finishes the season strongly, they would probably love to keep him to retain the excellent continuity that the starting offensive line has built this year, even if his improved play raises his price on the open market.
If he doesn’t improve, the Jets will have an opportunity to use their assets to find an upgrade at left guard. Still, they could take advantage of Simpson’s struggles by retaining him on the cheap, allowing them to maintain offensive line continuity at a bargain and allocate their premium resources toward more valuable positions than guard.
Sunday’s matchup against Orhorhoro will tell us a lot about Simpson’s outlook going into 2026.
EDGE Will McDonald
We’ve written quite a bit about Will McDonald this week. First, we highlighted McDonald’s overall struggles throughout the season, and in response, we debunked one of the popular defenses of his underwhelming production.
People have all sorts of opinions on the Jets’ 2023 first-round pick. Here are the facts: His 2025 numbers are nowhere close to what they were in 2024, and they are not even at the level of a league-average starter. Put as much or as little blame on McDonald as you’d like, but that’s where we’re at.
Per PFF, McDonald finished the 2024 season with 61 total pressures, good for 13th among edge rushers. Through 11 games in 2025, he has just 28 pressures, ranking 40th.
McDonald’s pressure rate this season is 10.4%, placing 42nd among the 63 edge rushers with at least 200 pass-rush snaps. Essentially, his pass-rush efficiency has been that of a below-average starter. Couple that with his vulnerability against the run (even if he has been slightly better this year), and McDonald hasn’t been a plus starter by any measure.
Maybe you believe those numbers are an accurate representation of his talent and impact, maybe you do not. Given McDonald’s obvious talent via the eye test and his track record of high-level impact via the numbers, it is understandable to believe that extenuating factors could be to blame for his lack of impact in 2025. Nonetheless, the reality is that his production simply isn’t where it needs to be.
After the 2024 season, McDonald seemed like an obvious long-term cornerstone for the Jets’ defense. In just his second season, he rushed the passer at a top-15 level for his position. The expectation was that he’d take another jump in 2025, establishing himself as one of the best edge pass rushers in the NFL.
Instead, McDonald has not only failed to take a jump, but he’s taken a significant step backward.
McDonald finds himself in a similar spot to Simpson. With over one-third of the season still in the future, McDonald has enough time to push his 2025 season-long numbers back up to their 2024 level if he finishes the year with a scorching hot run over the final six games. If he can do that, he can reclaim his status as the no-brainer building block that he appeared to be after 2024.
The problem for McDonald is that he could not have asked for a tougher matchup to kickstart this critical stretch of games. As a defensive end who plays most of his snaps on the right side, his matchup on Sunday will be the Falcons’ star left tackle, Jake Matthews. His 88.3 pass-blocking grade at PFF ranks second among all offensive linemen this year.
This is a fantastic opportunity for McDonald, though. As much as he would love to see a weak left tackle to pump up his numbers, it will send a louder message if he can produce against one of the league’s best pass protectors.
After all, proving he can beat star linemen is a box that McDonald has yet to check. Most of his production this year has come against mediocre or worse tackles. He has recorded six of his seven sacks in two games against the Steelers and Browns, whose left tackles were Broderick Jones (59.0 pass-blocking grade in 2025) and Cam Robinson (44.0).
Against quality pass protectors, McDonald has gone silent. He’s played five games against left tackles who currently have a pass-blocking grade of 75.0 or better in 2025 (good enough for top-15 among qualifiers):
- Tampa Bay’s Tristan Wirfs (78.2)
- Buffalo’s Dion Dawkins (79.3)
- Miami’s Patrick Paul (75.0)
- Denver’s Garett Bolles (88.3)
- New England’s Will Campbell (76.1)
In those five games, McDonald had zero sacks, two quarterback hits, 11 total pressures (2.2 per game), and a paltry 10% pressure rate. He had twice as many missed tackles in those games (four) as quarterback hits.
McDonald has shrunk against quality competition this year. If he wants the Jets’ new regime to treat him like a long-term building block, he has to start proving he can rise to the occasion against great left tackles.
Building blocks are supposed to help you win playoff games, and you’re never going to win many playoff games if your top edge rusher can’t beat the league’s best pass protectors. The playoff field rarely features many sieves at the tackle positions; it’s hard to get that far with a liability protecting the blind side.
For that reason, Jake Matthews is precisely the matchup McDonald needs at this crucial juncture of his career. If McDonald beats up Matthews on Sunday, and it jump-starts an impressive run to close the season, the Jets can start to take him seriously again as a potential core piece of their future.
If not, the Jets will likely seek to replace him in the 2026 starting lineup. Perhaps that involves trading him, perhaps it involves reducing him to a situational role, but either way, McDonald cannot be viewed as a part of the Jets’ nucleus if he keeps disappearing against good left tackles.